-MAIN-MENU-
Home
Email
Links
Search
Kentucky Resources Council, PO Box 1070, Frankfort, KY 40602 Phone [502] 875-2428

-MAIN-MENU-
Join Us
Photo/Audio
About KRC
PO Box 1070, Frankfort, KY 40602  Phone 502.875.2428, Fax 502.875.2845
HEADLINES & LINKS

  • Constitutionality of Metro Parks - Trinity Tennis Court Agreement Questioned  
  • KRC Asks KHSAA To Revise Protocols For Outdoor Sports Activity  
  • Power Plant Siting Board Deference To Local Zoning At Issue  
  • KRC Comments On Draft EIS for National "Biolab"  
  • KRC Applauds Decision By Governor Beshear to Withdraw Proposed Rule Allowing Electronic Multi-message Billboards  
  • Concerned About Strip Mining Abuses? Here Are Some Things You Can Do!  
  • Filson Historical Society Publishes Article By Sarah Lynn Cunningham On the Political Battles Over Air Pollution Control In Louisville  
  • Split Decision Leaves Cellphone Tower Siting Unreviewed By State Or Local Government  
  • Intervention In Net Metering Case Approved  
  • KRC Mourns The Death of "Mr. Chairman"  
  • Hazardous Waste Regulations Modified To Address KRC Concerns  
  • CAWS Appeals PSC Order Granting Kentucky-American Certificate For New Water Treatment Plant and Pipeline  
  • KRC Director Among Those Honored By UK College of Law  
  • KRC Director Speaks At "Energizing Kentucky" Conference  
  • KRC Comments on Public Notice Rules For Water Quality Certifications  
  • LEGISLATIVE WRAP-UP FROM THE 2008 REGULAR SESSION  
  • Billboard Industry Attempts Last-Minute Amendments  
  • KRC Asks Senators to Oppose Amendment Allowing Public Trees To Be Cut For Billboard Visibility  
  • On the Passing Of A Dear And Gentle Friend  
  • KRC and Citizens Coal Council Challenge OSM Rule Weakening Permit Block Sanction Against Mining Law Violators  
  • D.C. Court of Appeals Reaffirms Rejection of Coal Industry Effort to Weaken Protections Against Strip Mining In Parks, Wilderness Areas, National Forests, And Near Homes  
  • Amended HB 233 Protects Recycling Industry From Plastics Miscoding  
  • A poem from Nana Lampton  
  • Bill To Lift Nuclear Power Plant Construction Ban Opposed  
  • "Streamsaver Bill" Gets Hearing...Finally, and A Vote  
  • KRC Discusses Proposal to Lift Kentucky Ban On Nuclear Power Plants  
  • Reflections On The Passing Of Two Colleagues  
  • KRC URGES SENATORS TO OPPOSE CUTS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CLEAN-UP FUND  
  • KRC Urges House Leaders To Oppose Cutting Public Trees For Billboard Visibility   
  • Alternative Language On HB 233 Encourages Manufacturers to Design Containers With Recycling In Mind  
  • KRC Urges House Committee to Reject Bill That Could Damage Plastics Recycling Efforts in Kentucky  
  • MSD Variance Approving Relocation of Beargrass Creek on River Metals Property Is Remanded  
  • A Conversation With The Sierra Club At Activist Weekend  
  • KRC Endorses Fine Particulate Task Force Report  
  • Coal Industry Rebuffed In Effort to Weaken Protections Against Mining Near Homes, In Parks And Wilderness Areas  
  • Burlington Coat Factory Plan Approved With Changes Sought By Bashford Manor Area Neighbors  
  • Lynch Water Supply Reservoir Protected From Underground Mining  
  • 2008 REGULAR SESSION: Bills We're Watching: Preview Edition   
  • LEO Explores Kyoto, Carbon and Climate Change With KRC Director  
  • Graduation Address to Fall 2007 Neighborhood Institute Graduates  
  • AGREED ORDER ENTERED IN CHALLENGE TO DOE WATER DISCHARGE PERMIT FOR PADUCAH GASEOUS DIFFUSION PLANT  
  • KRC Recommends Improvements In Meth Lab Property Cleanup Program  
  • Conditions Added To Development Plan for Bellarmine Dorm Address Blasting, Dust, Lighting  
  • Deletion of state air toxics regulation from Kentucky's Clean Air Act SIP opposed  
  • Kentucky-American Water Hearing Concludes, Briefs Due December 28.  
  • What Utilities Can Do To Advance Energy Efficiency in Kentucky  
  • Fitz Receives Kentucky Heartwood’s Second Annual Stu Butler Memorial Award  
  • Help In Naming New Nature Center at Raven Run after Stu Butler  
  • Skewed Composition Of Legislative Panel on Climate Change Criticized  
  • Environmental Justice 101  
  • Draft Plan For Center For Renewable Energy Flawed   
  • “Carbon Constraints and the Future of Coal”  
  • Floodplain Variance Allowing Beargrass Creek Relocation Is Challenged  
  • Weakening of Stream Buffer Zone Rules Opposed  
  • LEGISLATIVE WRAP-UP FROM THE 2007 REGULAR AND SECOND EXTRAORDINARY SESSION   
  • Class Action Settlement In ZEON Chemical Air Emissions Case Unfair, Unreasonable, Unconscionable  
  • Upcoming KRC Events and Presentations  
  • Appeal Filed On Cabinet Order Upholding Issuance of Permits For Confined Hog Operations In Fulton, Carlisle and Hickman Counties  
  • KRC Appeals Nugent Sand & Gravel Mine Zoning Decision  
  • Kentucky Post Publishes KRC Testimony on Energy Policy  
  • KRC E-Mail Policy: No Attachments from KRC  Posted: August 30, 2003
    August 26, 2003

    To: KRC Members

    From: Tom FitzGerald

    Here at the Council, we take your e-mail privacy seriously. We attempt to avoid spreading any computer viruses, and never send or forward frivolous messages.

    Due to the recent concerns with virus attachments, KRC will NOT send any attached e-mails to our general mailing list. Instead, as issues or work of interest is generated by KRC, we will send you a message noting that the work has been posted (here) to our website, www.kyrc.org.

    If you receive any message from KRC that claims to have an attachment, or includes a questionable "subject," PLEASE let us know immediately in order that we may take steps to correct the problem.

    Thank you.

    Tom FitzGerald KRC


  • Where to take those old computers and monitors.  Posted: October 17, 2002
    There is an organization in Frankfort that will take old computers, as long as they are Pentium or above, and old printers and monitors. They will fix them, and in turn donate the equipment to needy families. The name of the organization is the Salvation Student Technology Center, 119 West Main Street, Frankfort, KY 40601. The phone number is 502/226-6062.

    Cartridges that contain ink for inkjet printers and toner for laser printers and copying machines are being accepted in Jefferson County at:

    # 595 Hubbards Lane.

    # 3520 Newburg Road.

    # 7219 Dixie Highway (beind the Southwest Government Center).

    # 9300 Whipps Mill Road (behind police station).

    # 7201 Outer Loop (behind the Central Government Center).

    # 10620 W. Manslick Road (behind the police station).

    The Salvation Army of Frankfort will also take some type of gear.


  • KRC has a new office address  Posted: August 18, 2001
    KRC has moved. Our new street address is: 213 St. Clair St. Suite 200. Court Square, Frankfort, 40601. Our mailing address is still the same P. O. Box 1070, 40602.

  • Constitutionality of Metro Parks - Trinity Tennis Court Agreement Questioned  Posted: August 25, 2008
    In an August 25th letter, KRC questions whether the July 2007 agreement for construction by a private high school of six tennis courts in Seneca Park in return for a set number of reserved use hours for those courts, violates the state constitution's limits on how governmental franchises and privileges are granted. To read the letter, click the headline.
  • KRC Comments On Draft EIS for National "Biolab"  Posted: August 4, 2008
    Click the headline to read KRC's comments on the draft environmental impact statement for the proposed National Bio and Agro-Defense Facility. Kentucky had been under consideration for the proposed "biolab" but is not one of the locations that was chosen for in-depth evaluation.
  • Concerned About Strip Mining Abuses? Here Are Some Things You Can Do!  Posted: July 29, 2008
    Click the headline for three simple actions you can take as a utility customer and a citizen of the Commonwealth to help curb mining abuses.
  • KRC Mourns The Death of "Mr. Chairman"  Posted: June 26, 2008
    KRC joins people across the Commonwealth in mourning the death and celebrating the life of former state Representative Gross Lindsay. KRC's Director worked with Rep. Lindsay on several bills during the past 30 years, and always admired his humor, his honesty, his kindness, and his willingness to stand against the popular tide in order to protect individual rights and liberties. When we would inquire about a bill that we hoped would not be heard, Rep. Lindsay would say only that the bill was "resting comfortably." Godspeed, Mr. Chairman, and may your loved ones find comfort in knowing that yours was a life well-lived.
  • KRC Director Speaks At "Energizing Kentucky" Conference  Posted: June 10, 2008
    Click the headline to read KRC Director Tom FitzGerald's concluding remarks at the June 3-4 "Energizing Kentucky" Conference. "Energizing Kentucky" is a collaborative effort of UK, U of L, Centre and Berea Colleges on energy policy. For more information on the initiative, visit www.energizingkentucky.org. Two additional conferences are planned.
  • KRC Comments on Public Notice Rules For Water Quality Certifications  Posted: May 14, 2008
    Many activities require a "certification" from the state under the Clean Water Act that the proposed activity will not violate the state's water quality standards. The Clean Water Act requires that the state give the public notice of applications for water quality certification, yet for years Kentucky has not done so. The state has proposed regulations to require public notice, and KRC submitted comments suggesting improvements in the proposed rules. To read KRC's comments, click the headline.
  • D.C. Court of Appeals Reaffirms Rejection of Coal Industry Effort to Weaken Protections Against Strip Mining In Parks, Wilderness Areas, National Forests, And Near Homes  Posted: March 17, 2008
    On March 14, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals denied the National Mining Association's Petitions for Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc of a January 15, 2008 decision, in which a unanimous three-judge panel of the Court had rejected the National Mining Association challenge to a 1999 federal rule that narrowly defined the "valid existing rights" exemption to protections against mining on public lands and near homes, churches and cemeteries. The 1999 rule required that a person seeking to mine within protected areas demonstrate that they had made a "good faith effort" to obtain all needed permits when the area became protected. The NMA had sought a broader interpretation that would allow mining in protected areas without such a demonstration. KRC defended the OSM rule along with the Department of Justice, and was ably represented by Walt Morris. The denial of rehearing means that the decision will become final unless the U.S. Supreme Court grants a discretionary review.
  • Amended HB 233 Protects Recycling Industry From Plastics Miscoding  Posted: March 12, 2008
    Click the headline to read KRC's letter in support of the GA version of HB 233, which has been amended to assure that plastic containers with barrier layers will not adversely affect existing recycling markets, The bill passed the Senate March 13 and will become law.
  • "Streamsaver Bill" Gets Hearing...Finally, and A Vote  Posted: March 7, 2008
    After several sessions languishing in the Natural Resources and Environment Committee without being heard, the "streamsaver bill," which would require improved management of soil and rock removed during surface coal extraction, received a hearing in two meetings of the House Appropriations and Revenue Committee. The March 4 meeting, available on line here , provided two expert witnesses discussing the values of headwater streams and the impact of dumping of mine "spoil" in those headwaters, as well as an explanation of the bill by its author, KRC's Director. The March 5 meeting included testimony from coal industry representatives and from KFTC members, and is on line here . The bill failed to pass out of committee.
  • Reflections On The Passing Of Two Colleagues  Posted: March 2, 2008
    KRC joins with the Environmental and Public Protection Cabinet community in mourning the passing and celebrating the lives of service of Keith Blair and Alec Mackenzie. They were, each in their way, faithful stewards of Kentucky's environment, who left us much too soon. In their honor, and in the memory of their dedicated years of selfless service to the Commonwealth and its people, we rededicate ourselves to the unfinished task of restoring justice and reason to environmental policy.
  • KRC URGES SENATORS TO OPPOSE CUTS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CLEAN-UP FUND  Posted: February 21, 2008
    SB 69, sponsored by Senator Ernie Harris, would cut by 21% the contributions of hazardous waste generators to the state hazardous waste management fund, weakening the state's ability to respond to emergency releases and spills of hazardous substances. To read KRC's letter, click the headline.
  • Alternative Language On HB 233 Encourages Manufacturers to Design Containers With Recycling In Mind  Posted: February 19, 2008
    A House Committee Substitute to HB 233 will be offered this week that allows the Cabient to approve coding of plastic containers based on the predominant resin provided that the manufacturer demonstrates that the container meets testing protocols to demonstrate that it will not adversely affect plastics recyclers. This approach will, if adopted, resolve an impasse that has spanned several legislative sessions concerning the coding of plastic containers with barrier layers. To read KRC's letter on the substitute, click the headline.
  • KRC Urges House Committee to Reject Bill That Could Damage Plastics Recycling Efforts in Kentucky  Posted: February 13, 2008
    KRC has asked that the House Natural Resources and Environment Committee reject HB 233, due to concerns that miscoding barrier bottles as a "1" implies that they contain only PET resin and could damage recycling efforts in the Commonwealth. To read the letter click the headline.
  • MSD Variance Approving Relocation of Beargrass Creek on River Metals Property Is Remanded  Posted: February 1, 2008
    On January 25, 2008, Jefferson Circuit Judge Kathleen Voor Montano issued an 18-page opinion in the case of Irish Hill Neighborhood Association et al v. MSD et al., an appeal filed by the Irish Hill Neighborhood Association and Lisa Dettlinger of the grant of a variance by the MSD Floodplain Board allowing relocation of Beargrass Creek in order to facilitate a new commercial development on the River Metals property in the Irish Hill Neighborhood. To read more, click the headline.
  • Coal Industry Rebuffed In Effort to Weaken Protections Against Mining Near Homes, In Parks And Wilderness Areas  Posted: January 16, 2008
    In a January 15, 2008 decision, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia rejected the National Mining Association challenge to a 1999 federal rule that narrowly defined the "valid existing rights" exemption to protections against mining on public lands and near homes, churches and cemeteries. The 1999 rule required that a person seeking to mine within protected areas demonstrate that they had made a "good faith effort" to obtain all needed permits when the area became protected. The NMA had sought a more liberal standard that would allow mining in protected areas without such a demonstration. KRC defended the OSM rule along with the Department of Justice, and was ably represented by Walt Morris.
  • Burlington Coat Factory Plan Approved With Changes Sought By Bashford Manor Area Neighbors  Posted: January 6, 2008
    The redevelopment of the former Bashford Manor Mall property continues with the approval of a development plan for Burlington Coat Factory. The plan included an outdoor amenity area, safe pedestrian access and delivery restrictions sought by Bashford Manor Area Association, which is represented by KRC.
  • 2008 REGULAR SESSION: Bills We're Watching: Preview Edition   Posted: January 6, 2008
    Click the headline for a review of prefiled environmental, conservation, consumer and general government bills of interest that will be introduced when the 2008 Session convenes in January.
  • Kentucky-American Water Hearing Concludes, Briefs Due December 28.  Posted: November 30, 2007
    3 days of hearing before the Public Service Commission on Kentucky-American Water Company's plans for a new water treatment plant and pipeline concluded on November 28, and the parties will file briefs on December 28. To watch the video podcast of the hearing, go to http://psc.ky.gov/agencies/psc/webcast/AV_Index.htm. The Case No. is 2007-00134.
  • Help In Naming New Nature Center at Raven Run after Stu Butler  Posted: November 17, 2007
    In memory of long-time environmental and community activist Stu Butler, his children have asked that Lexington's Division of Parks and Recreation name the new Nature Center at Raven Run Nature Preserve after Stu, who volunteered many hours over the years at Raven Run. Please email or write Parks and Recreation Director Jerry Hancock at 469 Parkway Drive, Lexington Ky. 40504 or jhancock@lfucg.com and support the naming of the new Nature Center after one of Kentucky's environmental heroes, the late Stu Butler.
  • Environmental Justice 101  Posted: November 13, 2007
    Click the headline to read the outline of a Continuing Legal Education seminar on Environmental Justice, presented at the Louisville Bar Center on November 13, 2007 by KRC's Director.

  • KRC Asks KHSAA To Revise Protocols For Outdoor Sports Activity  Posted: August 25, 2008
    In a letter to the Kentucky High School Athletics Association, KRC has asked KHSAA to work with pediatric health professionals and air pollution control officials to incorporate air pollution considerations into the protocols for limiting or canceling outdoor sports activities. To read the letter, click the headline.
  • Power Plant Siting Board Deference To Local Zoning At Issue  Posted: August 8, 2008
    An appeal of the approval of a construction certificate for a merchant power plant in Clark County, Kentucky raises the question of whether the state Siting Board must await local zoning and planning approval before it can process an application for construction approval. To read the opening brief in this appeal, click the headline.
  • KRC Applauds Decision By Governor Beshear to Withdraw Proposed Rule Allowing Electronic Multi-message Billboards  Posted: July 30, 2008
    A rule proposed by the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet that would have reversed long-standing Kentucky policy and allowed multi-message electronic billboards , will be withdrawn at the direction of Governoer Beshear. The Governor's office had not been briefed before the regulation was proposed, and became aware of it only after KRC contacted the office to express concern. To read KRC's letter to the Governor regarding electronic billboards, click the headline.
  • Filson Historical Society Publishes Article By Sarah Lynn Cunningham On the Political Battles Over Air Pollution Control In Louisville  Posted: July 29, 2008
    In an article published in the Spring 2008 issue of Ohio Valley History, long-time environmental advocate and environmental engineer Sarah Lynn Cunningham chronicles Louisville's political battles over air pollution control from the 1800's through the signing of the Clean Air Act in 1970. To read "From Smoke-Filled Skies to Smoke-Filled Rooms," go to http://greensmarts.us/files/From_Smoke-Filled_Skies_Full-Sized_.pdf.
  • Split Decision Leaves Cellphone Tower Siting Unreviewed By State Or Local Government  Posted: June 26, 2008
    A June 20, 2008 2-1 split decision of the Kentucky Court of Appeals reversing the Franklin Circuit Court, means that cell towers proposed to be built in communities with planning commissions that have not adopted zoning regulations for cell towers, will not be reviewed by state or local agencies for potential adverse impact on neighbors. At issue was a tower proposed to be built in Laurel County, which has countywide planning but zoning only in the City of London. The local planning body disclaimed jurisdiction over the tower siting since it was located outside London in the county, and the Public Service Commission determined that the mere adoption of countywide planning by Laurel County was sufficient to divest the PSC of responsibility to review the tower. The Shadoans, neighbors of the proposed tower, will seek further review of the Court of Appeals decision in order to assure that other landowners are not subject to this regulatory "limbo."
  • Intervention In Net Metering Case Approved  Posted: June 26, 2008
    Opportunities for net metering of electricity from renewable sources was expanded significantly with the passage of Senate Bill 83 by the 2008 Kentucky General Assembly. Among the provisions intended to increase the use of net metering by utility customers in the state is a mandate to the Public Service Commission to develop guidelines to standardize and simplify interconnection with the utility grid and the terms of net metering agreements. The PSC has opened a case, No. 2008-00169, and three parties representing the interests of consumers in increasing the use of renewable energy and net metering, Appalachia-Science in the Public Interest, Solar Energy Solutions, LLC, and NAPCEB-certified installer Joshua Bills, have been granted joint intervention status in the case. The utilities and intervenors (who are represented by KRC) will collaborate through August to attempt to achieve consensus on the terms of the new guidelines and tariff, and in the absence of consensus, formal proceedings will commence in late Fall.
  • Hazardous Waste Regulations Modified To Address KRC Concerns  Posted: June 24, 2008
    The Kentucky Division of Waste Management has filed with the Legislative Research Commission, amendments to 12 Kentucky hazardous waste regulations intended to incorporate changes to corresponding federal waste regulations. At KRC's suggestion, a number of changes were made to the proposed regulations in order both to address clerical errors and to assure that any alternative financial assurance requirements approved by the agency be enforceable and be subject to public notice and comment. To read KRC's commetns on the proposed regulations, click the headline.
  • CAWS Appeals PSC Order Granting Kentucky-American Certificate For New Water Treatment Plant and Pipeline  Posted: June 24, 2008
    On behalf of Citizens for Alternative Water Solutions, KRC has filed an appeal before the Franklin Circuit Court of the Public Service Commission Order granting Kentucky-American Water Company a certificate to construct a new 20 mgd water treatment plant on Pool 3 of the Kentucky River. To read the text of the appeal, click the headline.
  • KRC Director Among Those Honored By UK College of Law  Posted: June 19, 2008
    At a June 18 gathering in Lexington, Dean Vestal of the UK College of Law announced that KRC's Director Tom FitzGerald will be the first recipient of the "Professional Achievement Award;" one of four alumni awards established this year to honor graduates for their contributions to the practice of law and service to their communities.
  • LEGISLATIVE WRAP-UP FROM THE 2008 REGULAR SESSION  Posted: April 30, 2008
    As it has each legislative session since 1984, KRC has engaged in legislative advocacy before the General Assembly, to protect existing laws and regulations from efforts to weaken environmental protection or to abridge public access to the process of governance, and to assist in enactment of positive legislation on energy and the environment. Click the headline to read the wrap-up of KRC’s advocacy work during the 2008 Regular Session.
  • Billboard Industry Attempts Last-Minute Amendments  Posted: April 4, 2008
    With 2 legislative days remaining, the billboard industry lobbyists are frantically working to attach the perennial "cut public trees for billboard visibility" bill to a Senate bill in order to force a House floor vote. The industry introduced their bill in the House this year, but failed to get a committee vote on the measure. KRC appreciates the leadership of Speaker Richards and Representatives Hoffman and Adkins, and also appreciated Senator Guthrie's refusal to endanger two house bills with the amendment. KRC continues to work in opposition to the bill, since although the two remaining legislative days on April 14 and 15 are "veto" days, the rules could still be suspended and the billboard amendment could be attached to another bill.
  • KRC Asks Senators to Oppose Amendment Allowing Public Trees To Be Cut For Billboard Visibility  Posted: March 29, 2008
    Senator Boswell has filed Senate Floor Amendment 1 to House Bill 192, to allow cutting of public right-of-way trees to assure billboard visibility. In a letter to the Senate, KRC asks that the amendment be rejected.
  • On the Passing Of A Dear And Gentle Friend  Posted: March 29, 2008
    All of us at KRC were saddened to hear that our friend and client Sheryl Bolling has died. Sheryl, who lived in Letcher County, had the soul of a poet, and in her honor and memory, we share a few of her insights.
  • KRC and Citizens Coal Council Challenge OSM Rule Weakening Permit Block Sanction Against Mining Law Violators  Posted: March 17, 2008
    KRC and the Citizens Coal Council have filed for review by the District of Columbia District Court of a final rule published by the federal Office of Surface Mining that weakens the permit block sanction that has been used effectively in the past to prevent scofflaw mine owners and controllers from avoiding responsibility for violations of the federal surface mining laws. To read the text of the petition for review, filed on behalf of KRC and CCC by Jim Dougherty, click the headline.
  • A poem from Nana Lampton  Posted: March 10, 2008
    Click the headline to read "Mountain Tops" by Nana Lampton
  • Bill To Lift Nuclear Power Plant Construction Ban Opposed  Posted: March 10, 2008
    Click the headline to read KRC's letter to the Senate Agriculture and Natural Resources Committee opposing SB 156. The bill passed the committee and is awaiting action in the full Senate.
  • KRC Discusses Proposal to Lift Kentucky Ban On Nuclear Power Plants  Posted: March 2, 2008
    Click here to hear WEKU's news story concerning the proposed lifting of Kentucky's ban on nuclear plants.
  • KRC Urges House Leaders To Oppose Cutting Public Trees For Billboard Visibility   Posted: February 21, 2008
    In a letter sent to House Leaders Jody Richards, Rocky Adkins, and Charlie Hoffman, KRC has requested that leadership oppose this year's iteration of a perennial bill that would allow billboard companies to destroy public trees in rights of way in order to assure that billboards (even those that are nonconforming) can be seen by the motoring public. Click the headline to read the letter.
  • A Conversation With The Sierra Club At Activist Weekend  Posted: January 20, 2008
    Click the headline to read the text of the keynote speech given by KRC Director Tom FitzGerald at the Sierra Club's 2008 Activist Weekend
  • KRC Endorses Fine Particulate Task Force Report  Posted: January 17, 2008
    To read KRC's letter to the Metro Louisville Air Pollution District Board, click the headline.
  • All KRC Postings
    Click here to BROWSE All KRC Headlines and Postings

    Contact Information
    Use Policy
    Webmaster & Acknowledgments
    Contributions